One by one, the opposition voices are being silenced – Stephen Colbert, Jerry Greenfield (of Ben and Jerry’s), and now Jimmy Kimmel. NPR and PBS have been defunded. Even the highly respected Voice of America is off the air. Just like the governments in Communist China, North Korea, Hungary, and Russia, the Trump administration is moving to seize control of all the media. Trump and his minions have learned from their dictator-mentors that if the government’s voice is the only one that people hear, then that government can control not only the narrative but the citizens as well.
Unfortunately, this tactic works. Witness Russia where there is still surprisingly strong support for Putin despite the harsh economic sanctions and the failing military campaign in Ukraine. It’s because the Russian people are being told continuously by the government media that they are actually winning the war and that the West will soon bend to their will and cancel the sanctions. Hearing no other voices in opposition, especially since Putin poisoned Navalny, the Russians accept it as the truth.
The day may be coming when no one in our country will be allowed to say anything negative about the administration or its supporters regardless of the First Amendment. Further, if the Trumpists continue to follow the autocratic playbook, the government may soon begin monitoring social media for dissension or force the social media companies, some of whom are already on Trump’s side, to filter and report anything that is not fully consistent with their far-right agenda. All of this raises one question. Are we now seeing the end of freedom of speech?
The First Amendment also protects freedom of the press. But when largely right-leaning multi-billionaires own all the stations on television and radio, will the broadcast media become just mirrors of Fox News? Disney/ABC and Paramount/CBS have already “bent the knee” in order to avoid Trump’s wrath. Honest journalism, which reached its peak with the likes of Walter Cronkite, Edward R. Murrow, Dan Rather, and their contemporaries, seems to be completely dead. I wonder if the next season of “60 Minutes” will be filled with either irrelevant pablum or stories in praise of Trump. Likewise, newspapers and other news outlets, either willingly or under threats of lawsuits, may become simply repeaters of the government approved information, something like Pravda in the old USSR or today’s China Daily.
What about freedom of religion – also a part of the First Amendment? There is currently a strong movement by Christian Nationalists to claim that the United States was founded as a Christian-only country. But the Treaty of Tripoli, which was signed by President John Adams in 1797 (only six years after the ratification of the Bill of Rights), says the opposite. Article 11 of the treaty clearly states, “(T)he government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian Religion…” Despite this, there are those who believe that the laws of our nation should be based solely on their particular religion’s interpretation of God’s wishes.
Finally, there are the remaining First Amendment rights – the rights to assemble peacefully and to petition the government for redress. Remember that Trump has been granted broad immunity by SCOTUS. So if peaceful anti-Trump protestors are beaten, arrested, or even shot, I won’t be surprised. Nevertheless, I intend to continue to be one of those protestors.
Is the United States of America doomed? I don’t know. But in all my 78 years, I have never seen such an effort to openly turn our country into a dictatorship. Even Nixon was eventually forced to face the consequences of his illegal activities. But when every day brings fresh assaults on our democracy, I fear for tomorrow.