Opinion
Donald Trump and Republicans have proven – yet again — that they can bludgeon the (air) safety and (food) security and (financial) stability of the American people and win. That’s right – win.
Thanks to eight Democrats in the U.S. Senate, Republicans today can celebrate that they rolled the Democrats who won bigly in this past Tuesday’s elections. Republicans were being blamed by the American people for the federal shutdown, since they control every lever of the federal government.
Senator Jacky Rosen, who had voted against ending the shutdown all along, joined fellow Senator Catherine Cortez Masto who didn’t vote for the shutdown once. Eight Democrats were required to cross over to the other side — Nevada provided 25% of those votes. Nevada and New Hampshire are the only states whose Democratic Senators, all women, had both to vote to throw in the towel and give the Republicans the win. These are two of the smallest states in the country and together they provided 50% of the votes needed for the great cave.
What did the Democrats get? A promise to have a vote in the Senate (only) on extending tax subsidies for the Affordable Care Act, which will fail because the Republicans will vote against that. So, those who now can’t afford the huge premium increases in the ACA will presumably do without health insurance. (There were some other concessions Republicans made about ensuring government workers get back pay and would not be furloughed).
The Republicans in the House and Senate have voted more than 40 times to kill the Affordable Care Act since Democrats pushed this through under the leadership of Barack Obama, Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi more than 10 years ago — saving countless lives of Americans who could afford health care for the first time. Republicans could not win that vote to end it — but they did win de-funding much of it this year and eventually drowning it in the bathtub.
I have no doubt that Cortez Masto and Rosen were under enormous pressure from the Tourism Industrial Complex in Nevada who are being impacted by the air travel snarling orchestrated by Trump’s Transportation Department, thereby depressing visitors to Las Vegas and Reno. That affects jobs for Nevadans. There is the matter of air safety to consider — would you feel safe flying today with this mess in the sky created by Republicans? And food insecurity is a real issue. I’m sure neither could bear that children in Nevada were going hungry despite the best efforts — including our club’s — in stepping in to support food banks which has volunteers who work very hard feeding the vulnerable. The Republicans came off downright ghoulish fighting in the courts to stop SNAP benefits from being distributed.
So what do you think? There is a comments section below. Did Jacky Rosen and Catherine Cortez Masto do the right thing in voting to open the government without winning any health care concessions for the millions of people who will now go without health insurance? Was it time to give up the fight? Was the pain worth it? How do you think Democrats look today — like the adults in the room?
If you have an opinion, I welcome you to express it here on our website blog. (click on “leave a comment” on the left). We also have a Facebook where you can comment.